COMMENTS
I absolutely agree with you,Calvin.
No matter what industry you are in,if you hire a big dog, they are not going to give the personal approach a small company will.
I'm guessing you are a freelancer or someone who works for a small design firm.
This is all very very generalized making most of this your opinion.
Freelances can be pants and some bigger companies provide personal account managers to give the client that 'personal touch' that you speak of. Also, within bigger firms there can be a lot of competition for work meaning that workers there are always striving to outdo their colleagues in order to gain more recognition within the company.
I am immediately cautious of the writer's perspective here. A designer himself, Calvin is surreptitiously promoting self-interest under the guise of an informative perspective from a 'colleague'.
Always weigh the pros and cons of working with a design individual or studio/shop. Never do it because there is a quick 7-point list. It's a tough landscape for drumming up business these days, and this sort of tactic undermines professionalism and has the potential to erode design ethics.
Remember, your product is what's important. How you choose to get your business challenges met is more important than a designer's accessibility during off hours....
I agree with Michael on that it is GENERALLYy that smaller companies try harder than bigger ones. You are right, it depends on a company. But I have to strongly disagree with Patrick on his issue. Big companies often have enough clients, and their fame works for them, so very often they don't care about customer satisfaction, because they know that if that one customer complains, it's probably not going to hurt them. I am not from the design industry, so I might be partial.At the same time, to me there is not much difference between other industries and the design one in that respect. I remember listening to the tapes of a very succsessful real estate investor (Ron LeGrand), and he said that if you need to have repairs done choose a small company, not a big dog.They will do a decent job, and are not going to charge you an arm and a leg.
Wow. I certainly did not expect such a heated discussion from my top 7 however I welcome the discussion
Michael:
I agree with you Michael that my list is somewhat general, however my points are more my experiences regarding hiring smaller and larger firm. I have had better end results and service.
Patrick you wrote:
I am immediately cautious of the writer's perspective here. A designer himself, Calvin is surreptitiously promoting self-interest under the guise of an informative perspective from a 'colleague'.
Your comments sounds a little harsh for a list created from my own experience – but I’d still like to address it:
Your points are certainly valid with respect to my comparisons, as they are good and bad designers and design companies alike as noted in my post that one should completely “Research and vet the designer or design firm before hiring” With that said I would have to respectfully disagree with your assumptions regarding why I wrote this article. It is true that I own a small design firm but this article in particular was based completely from my experience when hiring for my web design projects. I've lost quite a bit of money dealing with companies who’s bottom line was payment and cared less about the final product. As I systematically moved to having my work done by smaller firms I noticed their eagerness to work not only to be paid but to produce products that not only represented me, but also their respective company’s brand. On a side note though. hypothetically, If I did post this article to “drum up business” and give my perspective of why I should be hired; I’m perplexed to understand why you would use the term “ surreptitiously promoting” as I would think that this article was far from sneakily promoting but rather very bold. And as a designer and businessman, bold is always better for me.
Larisa:
Interesting reference: I completely agree with your comments.
James:
Wow, I must have really struck a nerve here: I Just read your Top 7 and believe you have some valid points -much more detailed than my summary list . I think at the end of the day size doesn't matter but rather the company that you hire to do the work. For me if I had to choose between a large firm and a smaller firm with all else equal- quality of work, support, price, delivery date: The small company would win every time and that’s because for some strange reason I believe that smaller companies tend to be more personally connected to your brand than larger ones, and they are very careful to do an excellent job because they can use the completed projects as strong advertising for new projects: Frankly, I think that’s a huge factor in my choice between choosing between a small and large design firm – sounds a little cheesy-I know but the fact is I own a small design firm and every project I do for my clients becomes a project for my company’s Brand as well.
I completely agree, Calvin. As a freelancer myself, I would almost always recommend a small firm or freelancer to a potential client.
My post was merely to illustrate that there are some reasons to choose a large firm. I fear I came on a tad strong though, and like you said, really struck a nerve.
Oh well...I was just reading Darren Rowse's advice to create some controversy on your blog...I guess I succeeded! :-)
Being a freelance designer, I agree with everything thats being said in the blog.
The best way to look at it is "Would you call one person or ten persons ?".
So stick with the "small" .
Ashmith
www.ashmith.com